Sleeping on a lousy mattress is one of the reasons for which you may wake up all tired and with sore points.
If you’re poking around the internet for a better mattress, you may have run across some names a lot more than others. It’s the case with the Tuft&Needle and Casper which are common bed-in-box brands at the moment.
It’s great that you’ve been able to narrow down your choices to the two names, but it doesn’t mean you’re off the hook just yet. You still need to make a clear image of each of them so that you select the perfect mattress for your specific needs.
A kind Zoned support, a springy center, and the balanced foam is the selling points for the Casper, whereas the Tuft&Needle may convince you with its price and simple, yet effective performance. Without any further ado, let’s go over the details.
Do they share any similarities?
There are plenty of differences between the two, but we’re beginning with the things that have in common.
Listing the similar features are only going to complete the image of each mattress brand:
- Bounce- both mattresses are made with foam and include various layers that create a bouncy and comfortable structure.
- All-foam construction- Tuft&Needle and Casper are mattresses with the all-foam build. However, each brand uses its very own technology and principles to use the foam materials, rending the feel and the level of comfort to differ from one another
- Several models- you’re going to be able from a generous variety of models in each case. As long as you pretty much know what you want in a mattress, the diversity of models should work on your advantage.
How is Casper mattress built?
Without getting in many technical details, we’re going to take a thorough look at the main aspects of construction for each of the brands.
The cover of y mattress is made from a polyester blend that has a soft touch against the skin. It features a zipper, therefore removing it for cleaning isn’t going to be an issue.
- Comfort Layer
The comfort layer is made with foam (similar to latex), which explains the instant bounce. It reacts to pressure almost instantly, but it also lets you sink in, which is excellent for pressure release. The proprietary foam has sufficient cooling attributes, so you’re not going to sleep too hot.
- Contour layer
The section of memory foam is placed right under the comfort layer. It’s a material that reacts to pressure slower, which counts for the pressure relief and the deep body-contouring.
The third layer is where you find the Zoned Support. The segment is made with two kinds of long-lasting poly foam. Soft foam is placed at the ends of the bed, whereas the firmer type is placed in the center. The design is supposed to lift the hips while comforting the shoulders.
Heavy-duty poly foam is the material used for the bottom of the mattress, providing a durable structure.
What’s to say about the construction of Tuft&Needle?
It’s easier to make an idea about a mattress when you check its build:
The first layer of the Tuft&Needle mattress is made with polyester, which is well-known for its impressive breathability and ability to control the temperature.
- Comfort level
The Tuft&Needle uses its proprietary poly foam for the comfort layer (3″). It’s a highly responsive foam, ensuring the bounce and the high mobility. Due to the characteristic of this later, the chance for you to stay more “on top” of the bed and not in it, is way higher. The subtle addition of cooling gel in this layer reduces the risk of overheating.
- Support level
The 7″ base of high-density poly foam represents the support of the mattress. It helps the mattress maintain its shape and keeps you on top of the bed, with reduced risk for sinking in feel.
There is no transition layer for the Tuft&Needle, which is probably the main difference between the Tuft&Needle and y.
Do firmness and feeling make a distinction between the two?
It’s not enough to check the materials of a mattress; it’s also vital that you comprehend how the design affects the feel for a bed.
Feel is somewhat subjective, but we did our best to provide an honest and objective point of view.
When it comes to firmness, every user is going to have a personal take on it. Body shape, weight, and size matter a lot.
For Casper, customers rated the firmness for y mattress around 7 (with 1 being the softest mattress and 10 being the firmest type). According to the industry standard, the bed is a 6.5 medium firmness, which places it closer to the firmer side (but only by a bit).
The combination of foams lifts you and keeps you out of the structure. You may feel a bit of sinking in through the comfort and contour layers, but it’s only until you get to the Zoned Support and high-density poly foam base, you’re going to experience the pleasantness of the firm support. Don’t worry about feeling too stuck in the bed either. It’s why the combination sleepers should go for the Casper mattress anyway.
The layer of Zoned Support makes a difference, providing practical support, no matter how much you move in bed. Some positions may feel more comfortable than others, but most are going to find the Casper mattress comfy and able to provide pressure relief, no matter their sleeping position.
As for the Tuft&Needle, many customers are going to find it firmer (but not by a lot) than the Casper, placing it at a 7.5 on the firmness scale. The Tuft&Needle mattress is positively on the firm side, which results in another distinction between the two beds.
Remember that the Tuft&Needle has no transition layer (as it’s meant to provide a firmer feel), which explains the overall firmer feel. You’re going to sink through the comfort layer pretty fast and get to the sturdy foundation. But it doesn’t make the mattress terrible in any way; it only turns it into a more reliable option for the back and stomach sleepers that crave the firm support at the lumbar region for the proper spinal alignment.
The pressure issue is different for the Tuft&Needle as well. You may feel great pressure relief for the back and stomach, but not for the side. You may feel the firmness of the base pressing against your shoulders and hips (they’re the common delicate areas for the side sleepers).
Let’s check the differences!
You don’t need to be that meticulous or organized to notice the differences between the two. You may have to figure out some of the differences already, so scroll down for more:
- The number of layers
It’s the most apparent distinction between the two, with the Casper mattress featuring four, whereas the Tuft&Needle has only two. It may not seem like a big problem, but it’s the leading cause for the feel you get when sleeping on the mattress. The feeling of Casper is more balanced than the Tuft&Needle.
The variety of foams (the Zoned Support more than others) in the Casper is why there’s such a fantastic balance between support and pressure relief.
There’s a slight abrupt feel when you lay down on the Tuft&Needle as you go from the first soft layer right to the firm base.
We’re not saying that one experience is better than the other; we’re only highlighting the fact that the experiences differ a lot, especially if you have particular needs in terms of support/sinking in.
With that in mind, it’s expected for Casper to work for combination sleepers, whereas the Tuft&Needle satisfies the stomach and back sleepers a lot better.
All in all, we cannot say if one is better than the other, it’s really about how you like to sleep. When a pleasant balance between bounce and pressure relief means the world to you, the Casper mattress is your best shot. When firm support is what you fancy in a bed, take the leap of faith with a Tuft&Needle mattress instead.
What are the models from the two brands?
It’s always a good thing when you can find more than just one model from a mattress brand, and with the two, you may even end up feeling a bit overwhelmed.
- Casper Wave- it’s a luxurious model that is made with five plush layers of foam. It’s made with delicate materials that bring deep pressure relief, benefitting the side sleepers. Make sure you have the budget for it, as it’s the priciest model within Casper mattresses.
- Casper Essential-is the basic Casper model and it’s made with three layers of foam. It’s the most affordable model, and it provides a medium firm feel. Combo sleepers and back sleepers should try it.
Casper is a fantastic mattress for anyone looking for a model supporting the spine while receiving pressure relief to the delicate areas along the body (hips, shoulders, and the lower back).
- The Mint- is a newer model of the original Tuft&Needle, as it contains the transition layer for more plushness. It’s softer than the original Tuft&Needle and has a 6/10 grade on the firmness scale. If you only sleep on your side, you should give it a go. It’s pricier than the original Tuft&Needle too.
The Tuft&Needle is made with premium foams, so it’s going to last for a decade and more. It depends a lot on how much you care for it, nevertheless (spot clean regularly and rotating as well).
Which one should you buy?
At a glance, the two mattresses sure look a lot alike. After all, they’re both made with foam, which renders them to be responsive, supportive, and medium firm.
Once you give each one a try, you’re going to notice that there are numerous distinctions which set them apart.
Many are going to find Casper having a more balanced feel, and it’s the construction and the Zoned Support that explain the feeling. You’re going to see the mattress supportive, no matter how you sleep. As you get into its structure, your level of comfort is only going to improve. Side sleepers but mostly the combo sleepers are going to appreciate the Casper mattress.
An abrupt feel is the first impression when you lay down on the Tuft&Needle mattress, and it’s the two-layer design causing that feel. A sleeper is going to sink right through the comfort layer and feel the firm high-density poly foam base sooner than expected. The overall structure of the Tuft&Needle mattress is firmer than the Casper, becoming a more appropriate option for the stomach and back sleeper.
Let’s not forget the money part, with the Tuft&Needle being more affordable than the Casper mattress (which may seal the deal for some).
Here are the takeaways to remember when shopping:
- Casper- it has a balanced foam build, which improves comfort, no matter how you like to sleep throughout the night. The layer of Zoned Support is fantastic, lifting the hips and providing deep pressure relief to the shoulders.
- Tuft&Needle – it offers firm support that most back and stomach sleepers are going to appreciate. It’s an excellent value for the money, any given day.